3 1/2 CounterIntuitive Ways to Improve Your Email Response Rates
I was recently in a rather heated debate with a colleague over the pros and cons of HTML emails.
It got me thinking about the beliefs, thoughts, and feelings we have about the things we do in our businesses – and about how our beliefs, thoughts, and feelings don’t always hold up when we compare them to what actually happens when we do those things.
For me, the fun of marketing is all about understanding what’s really happening when, for instance, someone receives an email from me. Are the things I believe about how they’ll respond to that email really true? What happens if I tinker with what I’m sending out? Can I confirm the results in multiple tests?
With that in mind, here are three and a half counter-intuitive things I’ve tried and tested. They’re likely to improve your email response rates just as they did mine. But don’t take my word for it. Test them for yourself!
Note that I’m saying COUNTER-intuitive. This isn’t about obvious stuff like good headlines and strong calls to action. This is about the less-obvious things that may be tripping you up.
1. Drop the pictures
I know “they” say that images in your blog posts or emails improve your response rate. And that can be true, but there’s a very big IF attached: IF the picture is immediately, totally, and clearly relevant to what you’re writing about.
It can be surprisingly difficult to find pictures that really fulfill that requirement.
Meanwhile, even if your pictures are 100% relevant to your topic, there are other problems with images that can damage your response rates. I went into them in detail in a recent blog post, so I won’t cover them again here. The post is called “3 Ways Pictures Keep Your Readers from Reading your Email,” and you can find it at http://www.svahaconcepts.com/blog/communicating-your-message/3-ways-pictures-keep-your-readers-from-reading-your-email
2. Don’t mask URLs
I know. Those clear URLs – like the big long link I have in the paragraph above – are oooo-gly. And the whole point of HTML emails is that you can make them purty.
But what’s the point of pretty if you aren’t getting the results you want? If you include a link in your email, presumably it’s because you want your readers to click on it.
I’ve done several studies on this. Several, because I couldn’t believe the results I was getting.
The clear answer from my tests was that people will click on the long, ugly URL far more often than on a link that’s embedded in text.
In other words, people <em>don’t</em> click when the URL looks like this: “3 Ways Pictures Keep Your Readers from Reading your Email“.
My guess is that people are more comfortable clicking on a link when they feel like they know where they’re going. Or it could be that when the link is obviously a URL, it’s more obviously something to be clicked on.
The relevant point is, don’t mask your URLs. Even if they’re long and ugly, put them in. And then you can see for yourself if you get better results.
3 plus 1/2. Drop the formality
Got something important to say? REALLY want your reader to do something in response to your message?
Drop the formality in your layout and your language. (That’s how this tip rates the extra half: it’s referring to both format and writing style.)
I know it’s hard.
It’s easy to feel like your carefully-laid-out newsletter template is a key aspect of your brand and your credibility. It’s easy to worry that you won’t be taken seriously if you break the strict rules of grammar your high-school English teacher stuffed into your brain.
But a casual email-between-friends style is more likely to be read – especially if it’s not what you normally send.
When you write as if you’re writing to a friend, your readers will respond accordingly. So keep the formal template for your articles, but when you have something important to say (such as a key marketing message), drop the formality and go for casual.
Counter-intuitive is fun!
I know it may seem odd (or … counter-intuitive!), but playing with this sort of thing can be a lot of fun.
It’s all an experiment. Make like a mad scientist and try things out. After all, you can always go back to what you’re doing now – but the only way to get better results is to experiment with something new.
And if – or rather, when – someone unsubscribes, remember that whoever it was never going to be one of your ideal clients.
“Writing gives you the illusion of control, and then you realize it’s just an illusion, that people are going to bring their own stuff into it.” David Sedaris (1956-), American humorist, comedian, best-selling author, and radio contributor. From an interview in the Louisville Courier-Journal, June 5, 2005.
Posted under Communicating your message.
Tags: Credibility, Marketing
Comments: 2 - click to add yours!

I will be eternally grateful for your great gift of taking in to the fullest extent what it is that I
have to offer, living it, and then reflecting it back in terms of the potential experience of others.
You have given words to a process that defies words. And you’re constantly in a position to help
me continue to hone that, deeper and deeper and more and more resonantly, who I am and what I offer,
which is truly invaluable. — Jon Hansen,
Working together was absolutely key, and I think that’s what made it such a great
experience. I felt like you were my partner in this. I felt like my success was your
success. To me, someone who has that attitude and the skills to go with it —
that’s an unbeatable combination! — Daniel Stone,
I have a website I’m proud of — but for me, the hugest benefit has been
increased self-confidence. Because of the process we went through, and the validity that
came with the process, I trust what I think and I trust myself to speak about it. I have
greater confidence and clarity in my message about who I am and what I do. — Bev
Dwane AICI CIP,